9th District candidates challenging mail-in votes
By Stephen Oduntan
Contributing Writer
LOS ANGELES — Sixty-three votes separate Jose Ugarte and Estuardo Mazariegos in the race for the 9th City Council District seat more than two weeks after election day.. But as the candidates await the final count, their dispute has moved beyond who is winning to questions about how some mail ballots were collected — and what happened after voters surrendered them.
Ugarte, a former deputy chief of staff to outgoing Councilman Curren Price, led Mazariegos, a longtime community organizer, by 19,507 votes to 19,444 in unofficial results released Nov. 17. His advantage grew from 41 votes in the previous count, leaving the candidates with 50.08% and 49.92%, respectively.
At the center of the controversy are allegations from Mazariegos’ campaign that residents signed mail ballot envelopes and surrendered ballots they had not completed. The campaign says it gathered photographs and witness accounts raising questions about what happened to those ballots.
The Los Angeles County Registrar-Recorder referred the complaint to the District Attorney’s Office, which acknowledged reviewing the matter, according to the Los Angeles Times. No charges have been announced in connection with the allegations, and the review does not establish wrongdoing.
“The allegations made by the opposing campaign are categorically false and defamatory,” Ugarte said in a written statement. “At a time when claims of voter fraud are making national headlines, it is especially irresponsible to make such serious accusations without credible evidence.”
Ugarte said he intended to pursue legal options to protect his reputation and the rights of 9th District voters.
Mazariegos maintains that the complaints warrant investigation. In an interview, he described residents who allegedly surrendered signed but incomplete ballots to canvassers during the campaign’s final weeks.
A campaign representative who requested anonymity said three households had been identified where residents reported handing over incomplete ballots. According to the representative, the county’s tracking system subsequently showed those ballots as received.
The campaign has also submitted a recording of a resident’s account to election officials, according to NBC Los Angeles. The resident reportedly described canvassers taking three household members’ blank ballots after saying they would complete them.
The Wave has not independently verified those accounts. A ballot’s arrival at the Registrar-Recorder’s office does not establish who completed it or whether anyone interfered with the voter’s choices.
Mazariegos said his campaign had retained election counsel but stopped short of committing to a recount or legal challenge.
Ugarte’s spokeswoman, Angelina Dumarot, rejected the accusations.
“Every allegation deserves to be judged by the facts, not political rhetoric,” she said in a written statement. “Unsupported accusations should not be used to undermine public confidence in our elections.”
In a telephone interview, Dumarot dismissed the allegations involving the three households as baseless. She emphasized that California permits third parties to return mail ballots but did not directly answer whether Ugarte’s campaign authorized canvassers to collect ballots or what instructions they received concerning incomplete ballots.
The dispute has also drawn attention to a photograph of USC student Amir King depositing multiple ballots at a collection box. King, who supported Ugarte, defended his activities in a Nov. 9 Instagram statement, saying he encouraged students and friends to participate in the election.
The photograph alone does not establish misconduct. California permits voters to authorize another person to return their completed mail ballots, without a general numerical limit. Collectors must identify themselves on return envelopes, and compensation based on the number of ballots returned is prohibited.
The more consequential allegation is that ballots may have been completed without voters’ permission.
In a Nov. 17 investigation, Knock LA reported reviewing photographs, recordings and accounts from residents who alleged that incomplete ballots had been collected from their households. The publication also reported contacting voters whose names appeared on ballot materials.
Those accounts add detail to the allegations but do not establish that Ugarte directed improper ballot handling or that unlawful votes were counted.
Richard L. Hasen, an election-law professor at UCLA School of Law, said the distinction between collecting ballots and interfering with them is fundamental.
“A person is allowed to collect a voter’s completed and sealed mail ballot,” Hasen said in an email to The Wave. “That collector may not alter the contents of the ballot, fill it out, or discard it.”
Even if investigators substantiate improper handling, Hasen said, that would not automatically overturn the election.
“One [reason] for contesting an election is showing that illegal votes affected the outcome,” he said. “That may not be possible if it involves just a few ballots.”
Hasen added that anyone may request a recount but must pay the associated costs.
His assessment highlights the challenge confronting anyone contesting the results: establishing misconduct is different from demonstrating that illegal votes affected the outcome.
Election officials compare signatures on returned mail ballot envelopes against registration records before accepting ballots. Those safeguards help authenticate ballots but cannot establish whether someone improperly completed one before its return.
Meanwhile, the county continues processing ballots requiring voter responses or signature corrections. It has not released a specific estimate of outstanding ballots in the 9th District, leaving uncertainty about how much the margin could change.
“The latest election results show our lead growing,” Ugarte said. “In a race this close, with only ballots that still need to be cured remaining, that’s a significant gain. I trust the process and remain optimistic about the outcome.”
Ugarte has emphasized his City Hall experience and commitment to improving conditions across South Los Angeles.
“When I entered this race two years ago, I had one goal in mind: to make life better for families across South Central Los Angeles,” he said.
Mazariegos has campaigned on giving residents a greater voice in decisions affecting their neighborhoods. He said the grassroots coalition built during the race would continue regardless of the outcome.
“Win or lose, we continue organizing,” he said.
The election will determine who succeeds Price in a district represented by Black council members since 1963. With two Latino candidates competing, the outcome marks a historic shift in the district’s political representation.
The next vote update is scheduled for Nov. 19, with certification expected Nov. 27.
Stephen Oduntan is a freelance writer for Wave Newspapers.




